00:00
This is Mark Peterson with the June 2025 BlackRock Student of the Market update this month.
00:08
I have a handful of things for you on U.S. stocks. We'll talk about the May bounce-back, pretty powerful returns. We'll talk about the seasonal period that tends to be a little bit more sluggish for U.S. stocks. We'll talk about the recent drawdown as well, and where that sits relative to recent history. Then talk about one of the hot stories of 2025, the fact that international stocks are leading. Second half, we'll talk about inflation seasonality. We're actually moving into a good period for inflation seasonality. We'll look at the Fed rate pause. We've touched on this, but I still think it's very important to think about the Fed still on hold here, what that means for the second half of the year. Also work in inflation to that story, where do the Fed funds rate sit relative to inflation. Then, of course, alternatives have been another good story here in 2025, especially when stock and bond correlation is still sitting at historically high levels.
01:02
So let's begin with the second best May for U.S. stocks since 1950. You see on the far left side, U.S. stocks were up 6%, 6.3% to be exact in May, moves them into positive territory for the year. You can see where that stacks up with some of the other major asset classes. International stocks up almost 17% through the end of May. They actually had a decent May as well, up over 4.6%. U.S. bonds slightly negative in May, but still up 2.5% for the year. Diversification clearly bringing some value in 2025 here, it’s been a while since we’ve said that, but international bonds all adding to performance of a well-diversified portfolio, and you can see on the far right side, what that looks like historically. Only 1990 was better since 1950 for U.S. stocks, and you can see most of the period, stocks were higher seven months later. Only 1990, 1986, were stocks negative, and they were slightly negative over the next seven months, so you have a good May, often that momentum carries through the next seven months, which again is interesting, because normally this is a six-month window where stock returns aren't as good, and you see that on the next slide, the old stock market adage, “Sell in May, go away.”
02:23
You can see that from November 1st to April 30th, what we affectionately call Turkey to Tax, stocks averaged 7.4% in that six-month window going back to 1926, and then the window we're in now, May 1st to October 31st, what we call affectionately Mommies to Mummies, which of course May is the month of Mother's Day, October 31st being Halloween, that's the best we could do for that naming convention, you can see stocks only return 4.3%, on the far left side of the slide, but important to point out, look at the returns relative to cash. So “Sell in May, go away,” not sure where you're going when you go away there, but historically, stocks still outperform cash in these off months, these Mommies to Mummies period. I think that's important to remember, if you have investors who hear this “Sell in May, go away” adage, just still a good period to own stocks. 4.3% is still much better than you're going to get in a lot of other asset classes, so I think that's important to keep in mind. You can see it's been a little bit more dramatic over the last 50 years, which I think is interesting, probably a lot of reasons for that, and then probably most importantly, keep in mind that even though the longer-term trends hold seasonally, they can break based on what's happening in the near term in markets and the economy. The fundamentals can overwhelm some of these seasonal long-term patterns. You've seen over the last 10 years, it's been an equal split between Mommies to Mummies, Turkey to Tax. A great example was last year, we just finished up Turkey to Tax, we were actually negative for U.S. stocks, where Mommies to Mummies last year was up over 14%, and you see that in the bottom right-hand corner of the table. So interesting seasonal patterns, but understand, right, like a lot of things in the market and market history, they come with limitations.
04:19
Switching gears to the pullback that we saw in April, stocks were down almost to bear market territory, down 18.8%. You can see where that ranks versus some other recent pullbacks. Of course, 2022, when the Fed was raising rates and inflation was a challenge, stocks were down more, or 2020, during the pandemic, or even all the way back to the global financial crisis, you can see how significant that pullback was, so hopefully that visual helps folks really digest what this pullback looked like relative to recent history, but on the far right side, you can see the speed and the amount of the comeback following some of these big drawdown dates. You can see even since April, right, we're up 18.9%, on the bottom right-hand side of that table. I think that's a powerful story, just how resilient stocks have been. Betting against the U.S. stock market or the U.S. economy has been a bad bet here the last 60-70-80 years, and certainly seen that play out in a lot of these periods across the board. Some of these pullbacks, obviously, were very short-lived, like 2020 in the pandemic, or 2018. It will be interesting to see what history says about this recent period. Is this something that's going to be a quick pullback, or is this something that's going to linger a bit longer? Like some other examples on this page, like 2022, or of course 2009, one of the worst pullbacks in market history, but a good contrast, a nice visual, hopefully to put some perspective on what we went through in April.
05:54
Switching gears to international now, one of the big stories, as we started with, is international stocks outperforming year-to-date. It's been a nice change, nice to see that portion of the portfolio carry some weight. Again, international has outperformed 12 out of the last 15 calendar years, so it's been a while since we could say this. One of the interesting things that we thought it would be at least worthy of looking a little bit deeper on is the fact that the international index, or the benchmark for international stocks, has changed very little when it comes to some of these sector weights, especially within technology relative to the U.S. Look at the bottom left-hand corner of the table. This is 20 years of time, looking at 2005 versus 2025, just what the sector weights of the international and U.S. stock indices look like. Look at how much the U.S. has changed. You went from 14% technology weight back in 2005, and today it's 32%, essentially, in 2025, so an enormous change, more than double the change in that 20-year period, where look at the international sector. It was 6% back in 2005, it's 9% today. That's an enormous gap between the two, and this certainly creates a lot of difference from a performance standpoint, so when tech struggles, clearly international is going to benefit from that. It’s not going to be down as much. I think we saw that especially in the first quarter of this year. On the far right side of the slide here, we have correlations, so just how stock, U.S. stock and international stock move together, and you can see that correlation numbers come down, especially over the last three years, quite a bit, and some of that's due to the differences in that technology weight. So a little bit inside international investing, but I thought it was good to understand the differences between the two, and certainly if this maintains, it might make the diversification important between these two pieces, where you're getting a little bit more value, a little less technology internationally, and that could provide support in periods where technology isn't the leader, like we've seen in the first part of 2025.
08:16
Moving on to inflation seasonality, we talked about stock seasonality, inflation also has some seasonality built into it. Of course, they do seasonally adjust inflation, but there still seems to be what they call residual seasonality to the numbers, because it's pretty, pretty dramatic when you look at it. First half of the year, inflation averaged close to 3%, 2.8%, but in the second half of the year, it's a full half percent lower at 2.3%, so spending patterns, maybe there's more sales towards the end of the year. There just tends to be things that they cannot wring out of the inflation number, that are just seasonal in nature, and I thought that's interesting, and it actually translates over to bond returns on the far right side of the page. Of course, if inflation is lower, that's better for bonds because you're getting more income, right, relative to the level of inflation, so lower inflation certainly helps bonds and fixed income returns, and you see that play out in the second half of the year. I know there's so much concern about tariffs potentially impacting inflation, and I think that's going to be real tough to gauge how that starts to flow through to the number. Does it come in all at once? Does it come in in dribs and drabs? I think that's going to be really tough to calibrate, and maybe it gets absorbed by some of these things like inflation seasonality, and it can buffer some of the impact that we're going to see from tariffs in the second half of 2025.
09:51
And of course, that inflation story leads us to the Federal Reserve. What are they going to do in the second half of the year? The market's pricing in roughly two interest rate cuts – one in September, one in December – at this point. That always can change quickly, but you can see they've been on pause now since December, and it's not unusual to get a pause. We've mentioned this the last couple months in Student of the Market. You can see the pauses range between three-and-a-half to seven months, so I think it's important to understand this generally happens in a Fed rate cutting cycle. We're just going to move into one of the longer holds on record, and of course, that's due to the concern of the policy changes, the tariffs, everything we just touched on, but I thought it was interesting to look at performance once you resume interest rate cuts, Look at the far right side of the slide, good performance across the board in various categories, right, large cap growth leading the way, but strong performance across the board. Granted, in some of these periods, valuation, especially U.S. stocks, was a lot lower, right? Think about 2008, 2003 as well, 1990, stocks weren't nearly as expensive as they are today, so we need to temper the returns on the far right side of the slide, but you think about the dynamic that we always touch on, an economy that's staying away from recession, so that avoids recession, and a Federal Reserve that's lowering interest rates, that's a good combination for portfolios, and I think we can get back to that story here in the second half of 2025, if we do get those interest rate cuts in the second half of the year, and part of that story is what we see on the next slide.
11:29
Certainly up for debate where inflation's headed, certainly not a consensus agreement within BlackRock, what's going to be the impact of those tariffs, certainly a concern, but you can see it's the biggest gap between the Fed's funds rate and inflation. In this case, we're using the Federal Reserve's preferred inflation gauge, which is the PCE, and you can see 4.3% on the effective funds, Federal funds rate, versus 2.1 on the PCE inflation gauge, so that's a pretty big gap, biggest gap we've seen since 2007, and again, looking at the far right side of this slide, really echoing what we saw in the previous slide. Whenever you have a 2% or greater gap between Fed funds and inflation, look at the returns across a variety of asset classes, alternatives included here. Of course, alternatives do well when cash pays a little bit more, so that's when the Fed funds rate is higher than inflation, and that's certainly the case, but again, across some major asset classes. Again, large cap growth, you see a similar story here, echoing the previous slide, but I thought it was interesting that maybe this is the window, assuming inflation stays on a reasonable path here in the second half of the year, opens the door for the Fed to make those couple cuts in September and December.
12:54
Then finally, alternatives, something we've been a big fan of here in 2025, just looking at alternatives and their performance in this type of environment. Of course, they do well when those cash rates are a little bit higher, so when cash is paying more, these funds tend to be, these strategies tend to be cash plus, so if you're getting 4% or 5% on cash, you can make 2%, 3%, 4% more, all of a sudden, you're cooking from a return standpoint, and you see that historically. Also, the dynamic is what you see on this slide, and we've talked about it a lot, that stock and bond correlations have been historic. We had historically high stock and bond correlations at the end of the year, it was about 0.7. We're down under 0.7, or 66% of correlation over the last three years between stocks and bonds has been similar, but look at a higher correlation world, so the red bars on this slide, look at the returns of some of these alternative categories and strategies. They tend to do a lot better when stock and bond correlations are greater than 50%, and they tend to do worse when correlations are lower, and then look at the far right side. I think this might be the most compelling piece. Whenever stock and bond correlations have been really high, look at the far right side, that red bar for U.S. bonds, bond returns are terrible when stock and bond correlations are high, and what happens here is these are periods when stock and bonds are moving together in tandem. They're moving down, like we saw, especially last year, where we had a lot of months in a row, we had 14 months in a row in which stocks lost money, bonds lost money as well. That was an all-time record. That was another way to illustrate this correlation, but it also shows that bond returns really suffer in those environments. Certainly we've lived that the last bunch of years. We do think bonds are better positioned going forward, but I think this highlights a great diversification benefit between these alternative strategies and bonds is that when you get in these high correlation worlds, bond returns are likely going to struggle, but these alternatives can do very well, and you see on the bottom, very bottom side by the light bulb there, again, it has to do with cash rates being higher. When cash rates are high, correlations for stock and bonds tend to be higher, and that's a great environment for these alternative strategies, adding a ton of value and diversification to an overall portfolio, so going to continue to see that momentum in this space carry through in 2025 into 2026.
15:34
So that does it for us for June 2025 Student of the Market update. As always, if you Google BlackRock Student of the Market, you can find us out there, and you can submit suggestions for ideas and content there. We always encourage folks to do that, some of the best ideas come from folks across the country, but thanks again for listening. We'll see you next month on BlackRock, Student of the Market update.
iCRMH0625U/S-4566727
The old adage has held true in the past, as the 6-month period between May 1 and Oct. 31 has tended to return less than Nov. 1 to Apr. 30 – but recent years have been more mixed.
Fed rate pauses have tended to be short, with the current period being one of the longer periods since 1990. When cuts resumed previously, it tended to be a boon for the returns of many asset classes.
The gap between the Fed funds rate and PCE is the largest in more than 15 years, at 2.2%. When gaps of more than 2% occurred in the past, many asset classes saw strong returns over the following year.