Equity

How to seek powerful themes in client portfolios

Apr 01, 2025|ByJay Jacobs

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Thematic exposures are unique: Investing in forward-looking themes, like artificial intelligence or infrastructure, can introduce unique exposures and risks largely not captured by traditional portfolio building blocks like sectors, regions, or styles.
  • Thematic exposures may be rewarded: Companies involved in historically impactful themes, like smart phones and e-commerce, delivered significant outperformance compared to broader markets during their periods of rapid adoption.
  • Thematic exposures fit in portfolios: Advisors can consider adding thematic exposures to their client’s portfolios, introducing a new source of potential risk and return, while keeping overall volatility largely in-line.

WHAT ROLE CAN THEMATIC INVESTMENTS PLAY IN CLIENT PORTFOLIOS?

Thematic investing seeks to harness the return potential of emerging structural trends, like advancements in artificial intelligence or the rebuilding of US infrastructure. The impact of these trends feels undeniable, in 2024, companies identified as “AI- related” within the S&P 500 contributed nearly half of the index’s total returns1. We think such themes may play a growing role in driving returns going forward, with the Blackrock Investment Institute suggesting “investors should focus more on themes and less on broad asset classes as mega forces reshape whole economies” in their 2025 Outlook.

Yet portfolio management techniques for incorporating thematic investments have been less developed. Questions around how to choose themes, size positions, and fund them have resulted in thematic exposures being underutilized thus far compared to more common equity tilts like sectors and styles. In our analysis found here, we sought to answer these questions and establish a process for advisors looking to add thematic exposure to their portfolios.

There are three key takeaways from the paper.

1. THEMATIC EXPOSURES ARE UNIQUE

We found that thematic exposures carry a higher degree of unique risk – that is, risk not explained by common risk factors - compared to more traditional equity exposures like sectors and styles. This makes intuitive sense as theme-specific developments, like a breakthrough in AI technology, will impact AI stocks and is not explained by common risk factors like a firm’s geography, sector classification, or style tilt.

The implication for advisors is that adding themes to a portfolio may bring in new exposure not captured by existing allocations. By going beyond traditional portfolio building blocks, thematic exposures may expand a portfolio manager’s toolkit for potentially delivering long-term alpha.

Thematic tools offer unique risk

Average % of risk contribution for thematic, sector, value, & growth. Grey is the % of Identifiable Risk-average risk contributions from identifiable sources. Green is the % of Unique Risk-attributed to equity-specific risk not explained by broader market movements or traditional risk factors.

Source: BlackRock. Data as of 8/31/2024 relative to the MSCI ACWI IMI benchmark. A pre-2022 inception filter and a minimum AUM of $10M were applied to select iShares ETFs in each category. ‘Thematic’ refers to 8 specific thematic iShares ETFs: IDNA, ARTY, IHAK, TECB, IGF, IFRA, ICLN, and IDRV. ‘Sector’ encompasses all 11 iShares global sector ETFs: IXJ, IXN, REET, IXC, KXI, IXG, RXI, MXI, EXI, IXP, and JXI. ‘Value Style’ includes 5 iShares Value Style factor ETFs: VLUE, IVLU, ISVL, SVAL, and FOVL. ‘Growth Style’ covers 4 iShares Growth Style factor ETFs: EFG, IUSG, IWO, and IWP. Value and growth style factor tickers were selected to ensure broad representation across regions and market caps, reflecting the full range of available iShares offerings. The portion % of “Identifiable Risk” represents the sum of the average risk contributions from identifiable sources including sector, country, style, and foreign exchange (FX) risks for each group of funds. In contrast, “Unique Risk” refers to the average portion of risk attributable to equity specific risk, unexplained by the broader market or traditional risk factors.

 

Chart Description: The bar chart illustrates the average percentage breakdown of risk contribution for four ETF categories: thematic, sector, value style, and growth style. The grey portion represents the percentage of "Identifiable Risk", comprising average risk contributions from identifiable sources such as sector, country, style, and foreign exchange (FX) risks. The green portion represents the percentage of "Unique Risk", attributed to equity-specific risk that is not explained by broader market movements or traditional risk factors. The analysis highlights that thematic ETFs carry the highest average unique risk at 30%, compared to sector (24%), value style (16%), and growth style (19%) ETFs.


2. THEMATIC EXPOSURES MAY BE REWARDED

We found that past high-conviction themes, like smartphones and e-commerce, demonstrated clear outperformance compared to broader markets during their periods of rapid adoption. For example, during the smartphone boom from 2007-2019, stocks associated with the smartphone industry drastically outperformed the global stock market, with the total return of a hypothetical smartphone basket returning 269% compared to the MSCI ACWI’S 192%2. During this same period consumers shifted from Motorola flip phones to iPhones and Galaxys, with 91% of Americans currently owning a smartphone, up from just 35% in 2011.3

Past themes have rewarded the discerning investor

The graph on the left illustrates U.S. smartphone adoption (grey shaded area) increasing by 75% over the 12-year period from 2007 to 2019. During the same period, the smartphones theme (black line) outperformed the MSCI ACWI Index (white line) by 76%.

Source: I The smartphone theme is represented by a hypothetical smartphones basket created by BlackRock, a basket of 42 stocks which span a range of Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) sub-sectors including mobile network operator, smartphone manufacturer, communications infrastructure, semi-conductor company, battery manufacturer, smartphone software, and smartphone parts manufacturer. For all assumptions behind the smartphone basket, see the full paper. II Total return of the hypothetical smartphone basket vs. MSCI ACWI, rebased to 100 from 2007 to 2019 over the 12-year period. The smartphone basket returned 269% as of end December 2019 vs. 192% for MSCI ACWI Index. III Smartphone adoption based on percentage of U.S. consumers aged 13+ that own a smartphone. Source: Our World In Data and Comscore, Dec 2019. IV The e-commerce theme is captured by one of the earliest thematic indices, the MSCI ACWI Internet and Direct Retail Index. Reflects cumulative total returns (gross dividends) measured over the period of 5/31/2003 - 5/31/2023, rebased to 100. The MSCI ACWI Internet & Direct Marketing Retail Index has returned 1,928%, the Nasdaq Composite Index has returned 1010%, and the MSCI ACWI index has returned 512% over this 20-year period. Index performance is for illustrative purposes only. Index performance does not reflect any management fees, transactions costs or expenses. Indexes are unmanaged and one cannot invest directly in an index. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

 

Chart Description: The graph on the left illustrates U.S. smartphone adoption (grey shaded area) increasing by 75% over the 12-year period from 2007 to 2019. During the same period, the smartphones theme (black line) outperformed the MSCI ACWI Index (white line) by 76%.


3. THEMATIC EXPOSURES FIT IN PORTFOLIOS

We tested three approaches to introducing themes into advisors’ average equity portfolio: funding from sector exposures, funding from style exposures, and funding from new cash. Our analysis found overall portfolio risk remained largely unchanged, while the underlying risk profile incorporated more unique, theme-specific sources of return. This demonstrates that advisors can introduce themes into client portfolios from common existing positions, helping to diversify sources of potential risk and return, while still managing a client’s risk tolerance.

We created a step-by-step framework to help investors thoughtfully integrate thematic exposures alongside traditional buildings blocks into their portfolios. Advisors can consider the following five steps to add thematic positions to their portfolio:

Graphic describing the five steps in a framework to help investors thoughtfully integrate thematic exposures alongside traditional buildings blocks into their portfolios

CONCLUSION

Thematic exposures, underutilized in many portfolios today, can offer a significant opportunity to enhance outperformance potential in a risk-managed way. Thoughtfully integrating thematic exposures allows investors to tap into unique and diversified sources of risk and potential return tied to structural growth trends. While the ride in markets may have its fits and starts, setbacks and breakthroughs, we believe thematic investing holds enduring value in helping investors achieve their financial goals.

 

Read more about our case study and full explanation of our findings here:

iSHARES FUNDS

Explore a range of iShares ETFs to meet your clients’ investing goals.

SUBSCRIBE FOR THE LATEST MARKET INSIGHTS AND TRENDS

Get the latest on markets from BlackRock thought leaders including our models strategist, delivered weekly.
Please try again
First Name *
Last Name *
Email Address *
Company *
Thank you
Thank you
Thank you for your subscription
Jay Jacobs

Jay Jacobs

U.S. Head of Thematics and Active Equity ETFs at BlackRock

Jay Jacobs is the U.S. Head of Thematic and Active ETFs at BlackRock. In this role, Jay oversees the overall product strategy, thought leadership, and client engagement for the firm's thematic and active ETF business. Jay is also responsible for BlackRock's international ETF suite.

RELATED RESOURCES

  

ACCESS EXCLUSIVE TOOLS AND CONTENT

Obtain exclusive insights, CE courses, events, model allocations and portfolio analytics powered by Aladdin® technology.